10 Rare Error Quarters Worth More Than Face Value

Some quarters in circulation today are much more valuable than their 25-cent face value, especially if they feature unique errors or rare minting anomalies. Collectors are willing to pay significant premiums for these rare error quarters, which can fetch hundreds or even thousands of dollars depending on the error type and condition. Here’s a list of ten valuable error quarters and tips on identifying these hidden treasures in your change.

Rare Error Quarters Worth More Than Face Value

1. 1999-P Delaware Spitting Horse Quarter

The 1999 Delaware “Spitting Horse” quarter features a die break that creates a raised line extending from the horse’s mouth, giving the appearance of “spitting.” This error adds a distinctive character to the coin, making it a sought-after piece among collectors. Uncirculated examples can sell for up to $30, while circulated versions typically range from $5 to $15. When initially discovered, these coins were valued at over $100.

2. 2004-D Wisconsin Extra Leaf Quarter

This quarter has two notable error variations: one with an extra leaf above the corn stalk and the other with an extra leaf below it. The errors were the result of a minting mistake, making these coins particularly valuable. Depending on the variation and coin condition, these quarters can be worth between $50 and $100.

3. 2005 Minnesota Doubled Die Quarter

The 2005 Minnesota quarter displays a doubled die error, with certain variations showing an extra tree in the background. Values for these error coins range from $5 to $50, with the more pronounced doubling fetching higher prices.

4. 1976-D Bicentennial Quarter (Doubled Die Obverse)

The Bicentennial quarter is a well-known commemorative coin, but certain 1976-D quarters exhibit a doubled die error on the obverse. These rare error coins can be highly valuable in pristine condition, with prices reaching up to $8,400 for the best examples.

5. 2005-P Kansas “In God We Rust” Quarter

Some 2005 Kansas quarters display the motto “In God We Rust” instead of “In God We Trust” due to a grease-filled die error. Circulated coins with this error can sell for up to $50, while uncirculated ones are valued between $15 and $30.

6. 1964-D Washington Quarter

In 1964, the U.S. Mint ceased producing quarters with 90% silver content. However, a rare error involving a 1964-D Washington quarter with the high silver content makes it exceptionally valuable. In top condition, this error coin can fetch up to $8,000.

7. 1983-P Washington Quarter Spitting Eagle

Similar to the 1999 Delaware Spitting Horse, the 1983-P Washington quarter features a die clash error near the eagle’s beak, appearing as if the eagle is “spitting.” Pristine examples of this error coin can command prices around $500.

8. 2004-P Iowa Quarter

Though the 2004 Iowa quarter doesn’t feature a specific error, it remains one of the rarer state quarters in circulation. Uncirculated coins can be worth more than face value, typically around $1 or higher.

9. 1999-P Susan B. Anthony Struck on a Georgia Quarter

In a highly unusual error, a Georgia quarter was struck using a planchet intended for a Susan B. Anthony dollar. This rare mistake resulted in a record sale price of $10,925, making it a highly sought-after piece for collectors.

10. 2009-D District of Columbia Doubled Die Reverse Quarter

The 2009-D District of Columbia quarter has a doubled die reverse error, increasing its value significantly. One of these coins in mint condition sold for over $3,000, showcasing the appeal of rare error quarters to collectors.

Error Quarter	Mint Year	Type of Error	Value Range (in USD)
1999-P Delaware Spitting Horse	1999	Die Break	$5 – $30
2004-D Wisconsin Extra Leaf	2004	Extra High/Low Leaf	$50 – $100
2005 Minnesota Doubled Die	2005	Doubled Die	$5 – $50
2005-P Kansas “In God We Rust”	2005	Grease-filled Die	$15 – $50
1976-D Bicentennial DDO	1976	Doubled Die Obverse	Up to $8,400
1964-D Washington Quarter	1964	Silver Content	Up to $8,000
1983-P Washington Spitting Eagle	1983	Die Clash	Around $500
2004-P Iowa Quarter	2004	Scarcity	$1 – $10
1999-P SBA on Georgia Quarter	1999	Wrong Planchet	Up to $10,925
2009-D DC Doubled Die Reverse	2009	Doubled Die Reverse	Over $3,000

How to Identify and Collect Error Quarters

To find valuable error quarters, follow these tips:

1. Examine Your Pocket Change: Always inspect the quarters you receive. You may come across a rare coin without even realizing it.
2. Use a Magnifying Glass: Small details, such as die breaks, doubling, or unusual markings, may not be visible to the naked eye.
3. Research Online or Consult Experts: If you suspect an error, seek professional advice or use online resources to verify it.
4. Look for Mint Marks and Dates: Pay special attention to quarters minted in 1964, 1999, or specific years known for errors.

Collecting error quarters can be a rewarding hobby, as certain mistakes can greatly increase a coin’s value. While some errors are subtle, even minor variations can significantly boost a quarter’s worth, making it essential to inspect all your change.

FAQs: